1. Benjamin Franklin Shives born 22 March 1863 In Pennsylvania, died 3 April 1930. Married Lucinda Amanda Peck born 26 Apr 1864 , died 4 Mar 1940 In Thompson, Fulton, Pennsylvania.
i . Russell William Shives born 10 May 1886 in Pennsylvania. Died 2 September 1950
2. Russell William Shives born 10 May 1886 In Pennsylvania, died 2 September 1950. Married Margaret J Unknown born 1919 .