1. Robert Rutherford born Abt 1823 In New York, USA, died 6 Feb 1908 In Tompkins, New York, USA. Married Jane Gauley born Abt 1842 to James J Gauley and Amy Hawley .
i . Tillie H Rutherford born Jun 1878 in Tompkins, New York, USA.
2. Tillie H Rutherford born Jun 1878 In Tompkins, New York, USA.